Buying Gold and Silver in Indianapolis, Indiana

The largest city and the capital of the Indiana state, Indianapolis is also the 14th largest US city and the second most populous in the Midwest, after Chicago. It is a planned city for the new seat of the Indiana Government, being founded in 1821. It’s position as the center for several major Interstate highways which connect the state, gave it the nickname of the “Crossroads of America”.

Today, the capital is also the economic, transportation, commercial and cultural hub of the state. The economy of Indianapolis is based on transportation and logistics, business services, financial services, education, hospitality, tourism, and distribution services. The city is also famous for its niche markets in auto racing and amateur sports. Being the home of many of the best bullion and coin dealers in the state, Indianapolis is expected to become a huge attraction for investors and collectors all across the country since the adoption of the bullion sales tax exemption in 2016. Below you will find the list of wholesale and retail precious metal dealers located in this area.

Wholesale Gold and Silver Dealers:

1. The Coin Shop Address: 4710 W. 34th Street, Indianapolis, IN 46222-1227 Phone number: 317-291-1930 Hours of Operation: Monday-Friday 11-7 Services: Wholesale, Retail, Auctions, Buying and Estate Liquidation, Appraisals, and Newsletter. Specialties: United States Coins, Dollars, Gold Coins, 19th Century Silver Coins, Early Type, 20th Century Coins, Commemoratives, Modern Coins, Early Copper, Nickel Coinage, Small Cents, Colonial Coins, Territorial Issues, Patterns, Mint Errors, Bullion Coins, Tokens/Medals, World Coins, Currency, and Ancient Coins.

2. Lost Dutchman Rare Coins Inc. Address: 4983 N. Franklin Rd., Indianapolis, IN 46226 Phone number: 317-545-7650 Hours of Operation: Mon-Fri 10 - 6, Sat 9 - 3, Sun closed Services: Wholesale, Retail, Auctions, Buying and Estate Liquidation, Appraisals, Assists Collectors with Submissions, Newsletter, Helps Build NGC Registry Sets, Collector Sales, and Storefront. Specialties: United States Coins, Dollars, Gold Coins, 19th Century Silver Coins, Early Type, 20th Century Coins, Commemoratives, Modern Coins, Small Cents, Early Copper, Nickel Coinage, Patterns, Colonial Coins, Territorial Issues, Tokens/Medals, Mint Errors, Bullion Coins, Ancient Coins, World Coins, Currency, and Morgan and Peace Dollars.

3. Indy West Coins Address: 1776 Valleywood Drive, Avon, IN 46123 Phone number: 317-837-9825 Hours of Operation: Please Call - By Appointment Only Services: Wholesale, Retail, Appraisals, Auctions, and Buying and Estate Liquidation. Specialties: United States Coins, Dollars, Gold Coins, 19th Century Silver Coins, Early Type, 20th Century Coins, Commemoratives, Modern Coins, Early Copper, Nickel Coinage, Small Cents, Patterns, Bullion Coins, Mint Errors, and Currency.

4. Smith’s Coins Address: 1245 Sagamore Pkwy N, Lafayette, IN, 47904 Phone number: (765) 446-9535 Hours of Operation: M-F: 10 am-6 pm, Sat: 10 am-3 pm, Sun: CLOSED Services: Appraisals, Collector Sales, Assists Collectors with Submissions, Wholesale-to-the-Trade, and Storefront. Specialties: Bullion Coins, World Coins, and US Coins.

5. Silvertowne, L.P. Address: 120 E Union City Pike, P.O. Box 424, Winchester, IN 47394 Phone number: (765) 584-7481 Hours of Operation: Monday-Friday 9-5, Saturday 9-4 (Eastern) Services: Retail,  Auctions, Wholesale, Appraisals, Newsletter, Buying and Estate Liquidation, and Collector Sales. Specialties: United States Coins, Dollars, , Gold Coins, 19th Century Silver Coins, Early Type, 20th Century Coins, Commemoratives, Modern Coins, Early Copper, Nickel Coinage, Small Cents, Colonial Coins, Territorial Issues, Patterns, Mint Errors, Bullion Coins, Tokens/Medals, World Coins,  Currency, Ancient Coins, and Morgan and Peace Dollars.

6. The Coin Merchant Address: 2021 Hulman St. Terra Haute, IN 47803 Phone number: 812-235-0884 Hours of Operation: Monday-Friday 11-4, Saturday 9-2 Services: Wholesale, Retail, Auctions, Appraisals, Newsletter, and Buying and Estate Liquidation. Specialties: United States Coins, Dollars, Gold Coins, 19th Century Silver Coins, Early Type, 20th Century Coins, Commemoratives, Modern Coins, Early Copper, Nickel Coinage, Small Cents, Colonial Coins, Territorial Issues, Patterns, Mint Errors, Bullion Coins, Tokens/Medals, World Coins, Currency, and Ancient Coins.

7. Vierk’s Fine Jewelry Address: 1650 Main ST., Lafayette, IN 47904 Phone number: 765-447-0200 Hours of Operation: Mon.- Sat. 9 am - 5 am Thanksgiving-Christmas 9 am - 8 pm Sun. 11 am - 4 pm Services: Retail, Auctions, Wholesale, Buying and Estate Liquidation, Appraisals, and Newsletter. Specialties: United States Coins, Dollars,  Gold Coins, 19th Century Silver Coins, Early Type, 20th Century Coins, Commemoratives, Modern Coins, Early Copper, Nickel Coinage, Small Cents, Colonial Coins, Territorial Issues, Patterns, Mint Errors, Bullion Coins, Tokens/Medals, Ancient Coins, World Coins, and Currency.

Local Storefront / Retail Gold and Silver Stores:

1. Midwest Estate Buyers Address: 190 S. Main St., Zionsville, IN 46077 Phone number: 317-733-0099 Hours of Operation: Mon, Tue, Wed - 9-5, Thurs - 9-6, Fri - 9-4:30, Sat - 10-2, Sun - Closed

2. Engles Coin Shop Inc. Address: 3520 Founders Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46268 Phone number: (317) 875-0614

3. The Perfect Coin Corporation Address: Indianapolis, IN Phone number: (317) 696-9140

4. Zebone Jewelry Address: Indianapolis, IN Phone number: (317) 299-7580

5. GnS Eagle Address: P.O.Box 29363, Indianapolis, IN, 46229 Phone number: (317) 670-6092 Services: Appraisals, Auctions, Assists Collectors with Submissions, Helps Build NGC Registry Sets, and Collector Sales. Specialties: Bullion Coins, Morgan and Peace Dollars, Modern Coins, and US Coins.

6. Larry Hylton Address: Brownsburg, IN Phone number: (317) 852-8458

7. Wheatley’s Coin and Supply Address: 231 W Main St, Greenfield, IN 46140 Phone number: (317) 462-2625

8. Universal Gold & Silver Address: 4320 E. 10th Street, Indianapolis, IN 46201 Phone number: (317) 351-1900

9. Hoosier Gold Buyer Address: 5038 Kentucky Ave., Indianapolis, IN 46221 Phone number: (317) 702-2075

10. Castleton Square Gold & Silver Address: 6020 E 82nd St, Indianapolis, IN 46250 Phone number: (317) 841-9200

11. Diamond Stamp & Coin Address: 3440 N Shadeland Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46226 Phone number: (317) 356-9980

12. Ron’s Coins Address: 8686 Madison Ave # C, Indianapolis, IN 46227 Phone number: (317) 888-6873

13. Anthony’s Coin Shop Address: 6445 W Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46241 Phone number: (317) 496-5581

14. Michael’s Jewelry Address: 6251 Winthrop Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46220 Phone number: (317) 253-9505

15. Hardy’s Coin Shop Address: Columbus, IN Phone number: (812) 350-4722